last updated February 18, 2021
posted by Catharine Hannay
I've been having a lot of discussions lately with friends and colleagues about how to respond with compassion to people whose worldview we find incomprehensible.
Meanwhile, I'm frustrated by the tone of social media, where it feels like a lot of people are just slapping each other in the face with bumper stickers rather than engaging in thoughtful discussion.
As I mentioned a couple of weeks ago,
"Far too often, we start with an assumption about someone, and then look for evidence to support it... It's amazing how much people tend to demonize [other groups] rather than making any attempt to consider what could really be going on."
For the latest installment of the popular series of song playlists, I decided to focus on lyrics and videos that challenge the stereotypes and help all of us begin to see the world through different eyes.
As S.G. Goodman asks in 'The Way I Talk'
"Will you try hard to comprehend?"
Be Cool, L-Fresh the Lion (Sukhdeep Singh Bhogal)
"They judge me and think they've figured me out before I open my mouth... Try living in a home where every day you’re made to feel like a visitor... I’m not here for your amusement or here for you to abuse me... My heart's felt so much pain there’s been times I've almost tore it out."
Black Like Me, Mickey Guyton
"Little kid in a small town, I did my best just to fit in. Broke my heart on the playground when they said I was different... It shouldn't be twice as hard... If you think we live in the land of the free, you should try to be black like me."
Are you surprised to see the black experience represented by a figure skater? See 'Brother' (below) and Songs of the Civil Rights Movement and #blacklivesmatter for different perspectives. You may also like 'My Black is Beautiful' by teacher Lovely Hoffman, which I've included in the Song Playlist on Self-Compassion, Self-Acceptance, and Empathy
Born This Way, Lady Gaga
"I'm beautiful in my way 'cause God makes no mistakes. I'm on the right track, baby. I was born this way. Don't hide yourself in regret. Just love yourself and you're set."
For more songs like this, see the Song Playlist on Self-Acceptance.
Brother (Watching), Shad
"After a while, it sort of starts naggin at you... Saturated with negative images and a limited range of possibilities... and it's sad cause that naturally do sort of condition your mind and over time. That's what's attractive to you. So young blacks don't see themselves in scholastic pursuits or the more practical routes... And that narrow conception of what's black isn't true."
Brown Girl, Aaradhna
"I'm more than the colour of my skin. I'm the girl that likes to sing. All I know is what's within... God, please help them see they ain't no different from me. Not above, not beneath. Teach them equality... I'm more than what they think of me. More than the colour tones that they see."
Choices and Rights, Johnny Crescendo
"I want dignity from where I sit. I want choices and rights in our lives. I don't want you to speak for me. I got my own autonomy. I want choices and rights in our lives."
"When did the simple things get so complicated? When did the future stop feeling so far? When did our lives decide to play out like they did? But we're getting smarter, the farther and farther we go."
"Together, we all can be healed. Our dancing, our music, our way of life is slowly fading away.... Together, we all can be healed."
[OK, this isn't really a song like the others, but I think it definitely fits in with the theme of shaking up stereotypes.]
"We are one, but we are many. And from all the lands on earth we come... I'm the hot wind from the desert. I'm the black soil of the plains.... I am, we are, Australian."
I'm Deaf, Sean Forbes
"Look, I understand that you might be leery, getting music beats from the hard-of-hearing... Never be held back... Jimmy Abbott pitching with 1 hand, full of talent. Stevie Wonder never saw the keys, and Hellen Keller was capable of communicating... I'd rather not hear [than] not listen."
I've got a whole playlist of Songs in ASL on Mindfulness and Compassion, including 'Watch These Hands' by Sean Forbes. I've also included his song 'Hate' on the Multilingual Song Playlist on Unity, Diversity, Peace and Tolerance.
Indomitable, DJ Shub ft. Northern Cree Singers
[no lyrics available; electronic instrumental music with traditional Cree chanting]
Little Boxes, Malvina Reynolds
"There's doctors and there's lawyers and business executives...and they all have pretty children, and the children go to school. And the children go to summer camp, and then to the university, where they all get put in boxes, and they all come out the same."
"Then let us pray that come it may, (As come it will for a' that,) That Sense and Worth, o'er a' the earth, Shall bear the gree, an' a' that. For a' that, an' a' that, It's coming yet for a' that, That Man to Man, the world o'er, Shall brothers be for a' that."
translated lyrics: "A woman must be pretty. A woman must be silent. It's time for you to start listening to us. Don't try to tell this story... My present and my past. With this voice, I will narrate it today."
"I thought I'd end up selling my songs to shiny pop stars with millions of followers 'cause who would wanna see someone like me?... Now I'm here standing in the sun. Singing my home songs of freedom... Took a little bit of time to see. Took a little bravery. Took a little bit of soul searching. Took a little questioning... I've never been this happy in my life."
"All the other girls are thinner, so you skip another dinner... What's the matter with this picture? Girl, deep down you know better."
"Mine is clear, mine is very easy. My number one stereotype is just because I'm 6 foot two
260lbs doesn't mean you supposed to be afraid of me... I wish that I didn't sense that they were threatened by my presence without even knowing who I am."
"The message is clear [to indigenous people]. They wanted us to disappear. But we still here... It's important to make a presence. Representations at all levels."
"Wasn't recognized then as an equal person. And all these rules made by men cast shadows on your walls. And I'm sorry that you didn't get to do the things that had called out to you. And I promise that I'll advocate [for] the intentions that you have pursued."
"She said that I know what you're thinking when you hear the way I talk... Her brother's back at home tending to her daddy's land. He's farming for the businessman who takes the profit from his hand... Will you try hard to comprehend?"
We Are the Children, Chris Kando Iijima, Joanne Nobuko Miyamoto, "Charlie" Chin
"We are the children of the migrant worker. We are the offspring of the concentration camp. Sons and daughters of the railroad builder... We are a part of the Third World People who will leave their stamp on America."
We Are the Same, Mark Goffeney
video (As pictured in the image above, Mark Goffeney plays guitar with his feet because he has no arms.)
"We are more the same than you may think... And it's a shame to be ashamed."
Worth, Jade Turner
"I wish you could see that you matter... It feels like you just can't pick yourself up off the ground. But sometimes you gotta get lost before you're found. And I know it seems like there's just no other way, but believe me when I say you’re worth more than this."
I hope these songs help you and your students reflect on your own background and identity, and how you're similar to and different from the individuals portrayed in these videos. You may want to follow this up with Two Powerful Empathy Practices to Awaken Compassion.
Also be sure to check out the other song playlists. I spend a lot of time sorting through songs from a wide variety of musical styles, looking for hopeful and thought-provoking lyrics with no gratuitously offensive lyrics or images.
And there are hundreds more posts here at Mindful Teachers on: